- Practice Areas
- Publication Type
- Insights
- Practice Areas
- Publication Type
- Insights
- Home/Publications/Insurance Law Monthly
Causation: concurrent causes
As a result of the root decision in Wayne Tank & Pump Co Ltd v Employers’ Liability Assurance Corporation Ltd [1973] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 237 it is settled law in England that if a loss has two causes – whether they be independent (in that each could alone have caused the loss) or interdependent (in that the two causes worked together to cause the loss) – there is no recovery if either of the two causes is the subject of an express policy exclusion. By contrast, if there is an insured and an uninsured cause, the insured cause prevails. A different approach to concurrent causes may be found in Canada, most recently in the decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal in Green Rise Foods Inc v NV Hagelunie 2026 ONCA 334.
Online Published Date:
11 November 2026
Appeared in issue:
Vol 38 No 11 - 11 November 2026
Property insurance: increase of risk and fire exclusion
In Bellshill Property Ltd v Borland Insurance Ltd [2026] CSOH 71, Lord Sandison in the Outer House of the Court of Session considered whether a trial should be allowed to proceed in circumstances where a landlord was claiming against its tenant and its insurance broker for loss of a warehouse by fire. The insurers had avoided liability under the policy and the question was whether the broker or tenant had been at fault. That involved consideration as to whether there would have been coverage under the policy but for the conduct of the broker and tenant. Two clauses fell to be reviewed: an increase of risk clause; and a fire exclusion.
Online Published Date:
11 November 2026
Appeared in issue:
Vol 38 No 11 - 11 November 2026
War risks: exclusion for damage by or under government order
In Nord Stream AG v Lloyd’s Insurance Co SA and Another [2026] EWHC 1685 (Comm) Dame Clare Moulder discussed the insurance cover for two Baltic pipelines running from Russia to Germany and ruptured by explosions seven months after the invasion of Ukraine by Russia. The main question was whether a war risks exclusion had been satisfied, a question which the judge answered in favour of the insurers.
Online Published Date:
11 November 2026
Appeared in issue:
Vol 38 No 11 - 11 November 2026