i-law

Lloyd's Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly

CTL—HIT AND MISS IN THE SUPREME COURT

Michael Howard *

If the cost of repairing a ship after a casualty exceeds the insured value, her owners may claim for a constructive total loss. In The Renos, a ship was salved on Lloyd’s Form incorporating SCOPIC. It was common ground that the cost of salvage which enabled the ship to be taken to port and repaired could in principle be brought into the calculation as an expense necessary to achieve the repair. Hull insurers contended that SCOPIC payments were to be excluded from the calculation because (i) they were incurred before the Notice of Abandonment was given, and (ii) in any event they were not true salvage expenses. They failed on the first question, but succeeded on the second. This article argues that the Supreme Court was right on the first question and wrong on the second.

I. INTRODUCTORY

There were two questions for decision by the Supreme Court in The Renos.1 One of them related to the effect of the date on which a Notice of Abandonment is given and which the Court decided, with respect,2 in an unexceptionable fashion; the other resulted (as is submitted below) in a congeries of errors about the nature of salvage awards and of the SCOPIC clause and their respective relationships with constructive total loss.
The situation which gave rise to the questions was a commonplace one. In August 2012, the Renos (“the Vessel”) suffered an engine room fire while on passage in the Red Sea in the course of a laden voyage. The shipowners engaged salvors on the terms of Lloyd’s Open Form 2011, incorporating the SCOPIC clause. The Vessel was towed to one port for temporary repairs and another for final repairs. There was conflicting information as to whether the Vessel was a constructive total loss (“CTL”) or not. Broadly speaking, a ship is a CTL if the cost of repairing her after a casualty brought about by an insured peril

434

The rest of this document is only available to i-law.com online subscribers.

If you are already a subscriber, click Log In button.

Copyright © 2024 Maritime Insights & Intelligence Limited. Maritime Insights & Intelligence Limited is registered in England and Wales with company number 13831625 and address 5th Floor, 10 St Bride Street, London, EC4A 4AD, United Kingdom. Lloyd's List Intelligence is a trading name of Maritime Insights & Intelligence Limited.

Lloyd's is the registered trademark of the Society Incorporated by the Lloyd's Act 1871 by the name of Lloyd's.