We use cookies to improve your website experience. To learn about our use of cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our Cookie Policy. By continuing to use the website, you consent to our use of cookies. Close

Medical Law Reports RSS feed

AB v Leeds Teaching Hospital NHS Trust; Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust

Group litigation — Whether doctors owed duty of care to parents when obtaining consent for post-mortem examination — Negligent failure to warn of organ removal and retention — Whether parents had a duty to bury deceased child's body — Whether property in a body or body parts, removed organs or tissue — Whether right of possession to retain removed organs and tissue — Tort of wrongful interference with a body or removed organs or tissue — Whether psychiatric injury reasonably foreseeable — Sections 1 and 2 of the Human Tissue Act 1961 — Articles 8 and 9 ECHR — Exemplary and aggravated damages

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 01

Crouch v King's Healthcare NHS Trust

Part 36 payments and offers — Offers to settle money claims — No payment into court — Effect on liability for costs under Part 36 CPR — Permission to withdraw or reduce — Court's discretion

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 50

Ruscillo v Council for Regulation of Health Care Professionals

New Council to supervise self-regulation in health care — Right of appeal to the High Court from the decisions of self-regulatory bodies — Whether the right extends to appealing acquittals of serious professional misconduct or merely to decisions as to sanction — Whether a caution was unduly lenient in the circumstances of the second case considered — Guidance given as to the approach to be adopted by the Council and the court

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 65

Sowden v Lodge; Drury v Crookdake

Damages — Claims for future accommodation and care — Appropriate test to apply when deciding between private or residential based care regime — Defendant's entitlement to claim credit for future provision of Local Authority accommodation and care

[2005] LS Law Med 86

Chester v Afshar

Duty to warn of possibility of causa equina damage — Proof of causation necessary to establish liability — Claimant proving she would not have undergone operation at that time had she been informed of the risk — Effective cause of injury — Claimant's right to autonomy and dignity — Departure from causation principles

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 109

Gregg v Scott

Clinical negligence — Delay in diagnosis of cancer — Causation — Loss of a chance — Whether damages to be awarded for reduction in chances of survival for 10 years

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 130


European Convention on Human Rights article 5 — Detention of incapacitated patient — Legality of informal admission to hospital — Whether patient detained — Whether patient of unsound mind — Whether detention in accordance with a procedure prescribed by law — Whether sufficient protection against arbitrary detention — Whether judicial review and habeas corpus proceedings sufficient protection under ECHR article 5 § 4 — Mental Health Act 1983, section 131

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 169

Goodson v HM Coroner for Bedfordshire and Luton

Inquests — Deaths in hospital — Category of cases in which procedural obligation under ECHR article 2 to investigate death applied — Whether coroner required to obtain independent expert evidence on standard of medical care

[2005] LS Law Med 202

Sheffield City Council v E and S

Inherent jurisdiction of court — Whether alleged patient has capacity to marry — Preliminary issue — Questions to be put to experts assisting court — Whether capacity to marry specific to proposed spouse — Nature of marriage contract — Duties and responsibilities of marriage — Ability to understand marriage contract

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 223

Threlfall v General Optical Council

Disciplinary Committee of the General Optical Council — Duty to give reasons — Late reasons — Adequate reasons — Scope of duty of Optician referring patient to hospital — Serious professional misconduct.

[2005] LS Law Med 250

JD v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust

Negligence — Duty of care — Liability of healthcare professionals and social workers for diagnosis and investigation of child abuse — Whether duty of care “fair, just and reasonable”.

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 263

Moy v Pettmann Smith

Barrister's negligence — Duty to give advice at “court door” — Extent of advice to be given — Duty to explain and give reasons — Duty to warn client as to risks — Section 1(5) of the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978 and bar to appeal

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 293

Al Hamwi v Johnston

Consent to treatment — Antenatal screening advising of risks — Scope and nature of advice individual patient needs — Correcting misunderstandings — Breaking the chain of causation.

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 309

Bevan v General Medical Council

General Medical Council — Professional Conduct Committee — Sexual Misconduct — Emotionally vulnerable patient — Erasure — Appeal under section 40 Medical Act 1983 — Procedural unfairness — GMC seeking erasure — Appeal allowed — Suspension imposed

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 321

Markose v Epsom & St Helier NHS Trust

Spinal surgery — Option of conservative treatment — Extent to which options required to be discussed during consent procedure — Whether proper for consultant to recommend a particular course to the patient — Extent to which consultant must facilitate obtaining of a second opinion — Causation — Whether even assuming breach could be established, there was a causative link between surgery and neurological injury

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 334

McLarnon v Bradford District Care NHS Trust

Mental Health Act — Application for compulsory admission — Entitlement of managers to rely on facts stated in application — Compatibility with ECHR — Authority to treat — Need for second opinion after three months — Starting point of period

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 345

R (Campbell) v General Medical Council

Judicial review of the Professional Conduct Committee of the General Medical Council — Whether personal mitigation relevant to determination of serious professional misconduct — Rules 28 and 29 of the General Medical Council Preliminary Proceedings Committee and Professional Conduct Committee (Procedure) Rules Order of Council 1988 — Adequacy of reasons — Double jeopardy — Whether declaratory relief appropriate remedy

[2005] LS Law Med 353

CRHP v General Medical Council

Professional disciplinary procedures of the General Medical Council — Misreporting of child abuse — Whether erasure from the Medical Register only appropriate sanction — Whether conditions imposed on registration too lenient

[2005] LS Law Med 365

Godbold v Mahmood

Damages — Claims for future loss including accommodation and care — Whether future care to be provided in claimant's own home or in care home — Whether damages to be assessed on basis of private or state provision — Whether and to what extent liability to be discharged by order for periodical payments

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 379

London Borough of Islington v University College London Hospital

Duty of care — Statutory provision of care by local authority to person injured by negligence of NHS Trust — Recoverability of costs of care by local authority directly from NHS Trust — Whether duty of care owed by negligent tortfeasor to third party — Whether such a duty would be reasonably foreseeable, proximate and just, fair and reasonable

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 386

R (Burke) v GMC

Medical treatment — Judicial review — Declaration as to lawfulness of GMC guidance — Declaration as to lawfulness of treatment — Best interests and autonomy of competent patient — the doctor's duty to care — European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights, articles 2, 3, and 8 — Procedure: whether necessary to obtain court authorization before withdrawing artificial nutrition and hydration

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 403

McDonnell v Holwerda

Clinical Negligence — Duty of care — Breach of duty — Standard of care — Duty of GP to refer to hospital before specific symptoms develop — Assessment of risk relevant to breach of duty — Standard of care when treating children

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 423

Watson v GMC

General Medical Council — Procedures of Fitness to Practise Panel where practitioner's health in issue — Whether medical assessors exceeded proper role — Whether opportunity given to practitioner to address Panel on substance of assessors' advice — Whether serious procedural error in proceedings

[2005] LS Law Med 435

Brian Warwicker v HOK International

Damages — Joint tortfeasors — Contribution claim — Apportionment — Responsibility for damage — Blameworthiness and causative potency — Whether non-causative factors may be taken into account

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 464

Wyatt v Portsmouth Hospital NHS Trust

Treatment of child — Best interests — Whether in best interests to ventilate seriously ill and brain damaged baby — Whether intolerability touchstone of best interests — Whether appropriate to grant declaration when circumstances could change

[2005] Lloyd's Rep Med 474