International Construction Law Review
DESIGN LIFE OR SERVICE LIFE: WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE?
Dr Donald Charrett BE, LLB, MConstLaw, PhD, FIEAust, FCIArb
INTRODUCTION
Many construction law cases involve an intersection of legal and technical issues related to a constructed facility, such as defects, fitness for purpose, durability, strength, serviceability, maintainability or operability. The common denominator of these issues is the design of the facility.
The design of a constructed facility involves all the large and small decisions required to determine its form, how its elements work individually and in combination to fulfil their functional requirements, what materials will be used in construction, how these are connected together, how the facility is to be constructed, and how it should be maintained and operated. It is the design that determines not only the form and nature of the construction, but also the economic characteristics of the constructed facility such as its durability, the ongoing operating and maintenance costs and ultimately its commercial life.
This paper discusses a number of aspects of structural design to explain the difference between design life and service life, an issue that may be important in the context of design and construct contracts. The “default” legal obligation to prepare a design with due skill and care is contrasted with the common contractual obligation for a constructed facility to be fit for purpose. These issues are illustrated by reference to recent case law.
DESIGN OF CONSTRUCTED FACILITIES
Those responsible for the design of constructed facilities are constrained by, inter alia, the laws of physics, the known, available and usable mathematics, and the known “state of the art” of the relevant technology. Notwithstanding the continual advances in technology and the “state of the art”, the design and engineering of facilities “for the use and convenience of man”1 will continue to create new frontiers, and reveal hitherto unknown gaps in our knowledge. In this paper “state of the art” refers to the art and science that would be applied by competent and experienced practitioners involved
Pt 1] Design Life or Service Life: What is the Difference?
17